Staff Safety Is About Having Options
Every medical practice should have a plan for keeping its staff safe. But is having a panic button enough?
Whether you are opening a brand-new medical practice or have been operating successfully for 20 years, staff safety deserves ongoing attention. A practice can run smoothly for years without a serious incident, but that does not mean an unexpected situation will never occur.
An angry patient, a distressed visitor, an escalating disagreement or an unexpected medical emergency can quickly change the atmosphere of a consultation room. When it happens, staff need to know they can get help quickly, confidently and appropriately.
The question is not whether your practice has a panic button. It is whether your team has enough options when they need assistance.
You Already Have Safety Measures in Place. Why Not Add Another?
Think about the other protective measures your practice already uses.
You probably have fire extinguishers, smoke detectors, antivirus software, alarms and perhaps security cameras. These measures address different risks, helping protect your people, premises and information.
You do not remove your smoke detectors because you have fire extinguishers. Nor would you rely on antivirus software to protect against every possible security threat.
Each measure serves a different purpose.
Staff safety deserves the same thinking. A traditional panic button can be an important part of your safety arrangements, but it does not necessarily address every situation your team may encounter.
Having an additional way to request assistance gives staff another option when circumstances do not suit the traditional approach.
The Limitations of Traditional Panic Buttons
Panic buttons are designed to summon help during an emergency. However, their effectiveness depends on their placement, accessibility, operation and the response they trigger.
1. Location can make all the difference
Some fixed panic buttons are positioned beneath desks or in locations that are difficult to reach during a confrontation. In some consultation rooms, a button may be located behind the patient rather than somewhere the clinician can comfortably access.
If a staff member has to move towards an agitated person, reach awkwardly or draw attention to their actions, activating the button may become difficult.
A safety device is only useful when it can be accessed when needed.
2. Accidental activations happen
Buttons can be pressed accidentally by knees, bags, children or everyday movements around a desk. Depending on the system, an accidental activation may trigger an unnecessary emergency response, causing disruption and concern.
This does not make panic buttons a bad idea. It highlights the importance of considering how a system works in the real environment of a busy medical practice.
3. Not every situation calls for police or security
There are situations where contacting police or security is absolutely appropriate. When someone poses an immediate threat, staff should follow their emergency procedures and seek emergency assistance when required. But not every difficult interaction reaches that level.
A patient may be becoming increasingly frustrated. A conversation may be escalating. A clinician may simply feel uncomfortable being alone with someone whose behaviour is becoming unpredictable.
In these circumstances, a discreet request for another staff member to enter the room may help provide support, interrupt the escalation or allow the situation to be managed more calmly.
If staff believe that pressing their only available alert will automatically trigger a response, they consider disproportionate to the situation, they may hesitate to use it. That hesitation matters. A system that staff are reluctant to activate may not provide the practical support they need in every circumstance.
4. What happens if your only option fails?
This is perhaps the most important consideration. A button may be obstructed, damaged, disconnected, out of reach or not transmitting correctly. Staff may not know where it is located or how to operate it, particularly if they are working in an unfamiliar room.
These are not merely hypothetical concerns. In July 2025, WorkSafe Victoria published a safety alert reporting that healthcare workers had been unable to activate duress alarms because they did not know where to find them or how to use them.
WorkSafe recommended regular testing, accessible and unobstructed buttons, appropriate staff training and reviews of alarm systems.
The lesson is not to abandon panic buttons. It is to recognise that even established safety measures need to be checked, maintained and supported by other procedures. And if your only method of requesting assistance is unavailable at the moment you need it, what is your backup?
A Different Situation Requires a Different Response
Imagine a GP consulting with a patient who becomes increasingly angry about a treatment decision. The doctor feels uncomfortable and would prefer another team member to join the consultation before the situation escalates. They do not necessarily need police attendance at that moment, but they do need support. Or consider a receptionist dealing with an increasingly aggressive visitor while colleagues are working elsewhere in the practice.
In both situations, the ability to discreetly request assistance from another staff member could make a meaningful difference. Of course, no alert system can guarantee that a situation will de-escalate. Staff must still follow their practice’s safety procedures, assess the level of risk and seek emergency assistance when necessary.
The important point is that there should be more than one way to get help.
The Australian Medical Association’s November 2024 position statement, Managing and responding to violence in the medical workplace, supports a multilayered approach to workplace safety, including risk management, physical protection, training and ongoing evaluation. Its principles are intended to apply to private practices and community settings wherever practicable.
Safety is not about finding one perfect solution. It is about putting appropriate measures in place to address different circumstances.
A Safer Approach for New and Established Practices
For a new medical practice, staff safety should be considered from the beginning. Think about consultation room layouts, the placement of existing alarms, staff training and how colleagues can communicate when someone needs assistance.
For an established practice, it is worth reviewing the arrangements already in place.
Ask your team a few simple questions:
• Can you easily reach your panic button from where you normally work?
• Do you know exactly what happens when it is activated?
• Would you feel comfortable using it if you needed another staff member’s assistance but did not believe police attendance was necessary?
• What would you do if your usual alert method did not work?
• Do you have another reliable way to request help?
These questions are not intended to create unnecessary concern. They are an opportunity to identify gaps before an incident occurs. Importantly, additional safety measures do not have to mean replacing existing equipment or undertaking an expensive infrastructure project. Sometimes, adding another practical option can strengthen the arrangements you already have.
EXHAIL: Another Way to Get Help
This is where EXHAIL offers medical practices another choice.
EXHAIL is an Australian-developed, software-based staff duress and safety alert system designed for medical practices. It works alongside your existing safety arrangements, providing an additional way for staff to discreetly request assistance.
Using a simple desktop application, a staff member can activate an alert with a double-click. The notification is routed to designated computers within the practice, helping colleagues know that assistance is needed.
Rather than relying solely on a fixed panic button, staff have another way to communicate a need for support. Depending on the situation, that may mean a colleague entering a room, checking on a team member or helping manage an escalating interaction.
EXHAIL does not replace panic buttons, alarms, telephones, intercoms, security systems or emergency services. It complements them by providing another option within your existing working environment.
It is also designed to be practical and affordable. There is no additional alert hardware required, it supports Windows and Mac computers, and it does not require an internet connection to operate after installation.
For practices that already have their safety measures in place, EXHAIL can be added without needing to start again.
No system can prevent every incident, and no alert should be treated as a guarantee of safety. But giving staff another way to request help can be a worthwhile addition to a broader safety plan.
The Bottom Line: One Option Is Not Always Enough
Your practice may have operated for years without a serious incident. You may already have panic buttons, alarms and well-established procedures. Hopefully, you will rarely, if ever, need to use them.
But preparation is about being ready for the situation you hope never happens.
If your practice already invests in measures to protect its people, it is worth asking whether your team has enough ways to get assistance when circumstances change.
A panic button remains an important safety tool. It simply does not have to be the only one. EXHAIL gives your practice another option, another way to request help and another layer of support for your team.
Because when it comes to staff safety, having a choice can make all the difference.
Explore EXHAIL and discover how an additional layer of staff safety can fit into your practice.
References and Further Reading
1. WorkSafe Victoria (2025) — Duress alarms in healthcare. Guidance on alarm accessibility, testing, staff training and situations where workers could not activate alarms.
2. Australian Medical Association (2024) — Managing and responding to violence in the medical workplace. Position statement supporting a multilayered approach to workplace safety, including in private medical practices.
3. Safe Work Australia (2024) — New report on workplace and work-related violence and aggression in Australia. National findings on workplace violence, aggression and the importance of effective controls.



